- Sonoma County Insider
- Posts
- Price Cuts Rising While Rates Stay Stuck
Price Cuts Rising While Rates Stay Stuck

Pour yourself something good and settle in, because this week's data reads like a wine country thriller with plot twists the Fed didn't see coming. We're watching nearly a quarter of local sellers slash prices in what might be tactical repositioning or might be the sound of optimism meeting reality, the central bank just proved it can't agree on anything except confusion, and up in Healdsburg they're tackling the one conversation most people avoid until it's too late—how to plan your exit with the same care you planned your entrance into wine country.
Nearly one in four Sonoma County homes just dropped their asking price, with luxury sellers either holding firm through sheer confidence or occasionally panicking and slashing over a million bucks to find that increasingly mythical high-end buyer.
The Fed cut rates again but can't agree whether to keep cutting, which means your mortgage is staying stubbornly above 6% until at least 2027 while economists debate whether we're getting a "gradual thaw" or just more expensive waiting.
Healdsburg just launched California's first city-funded end-of-life planning program, treating death preparation like public infrastructure and proving that wine country's most forward-thinking community isn't afraid to plan for the inevitable with the same care they apply to vineyard management.
Ready to see how price cuts, rate chaos, and mortality planning connect to your wine country investment strategy? Let's dive in.
If you were sent this newsletter by a friend, you can get your very own copy by signing up here
Real Estate News
Nearly 1 in 4 Wine Country Homes Just Cut Prices
While 18% of home listings nationwide have slashed prices, Sonoma County is seeing deeper market recalibration. Nearly one-quarter of local listings (23.8%) dropped asking prices in the past 30 days—161 properties out of 676 active listings—suggesting sellers are reading the room on buyer resistance.
The national context
The inventory-starved Northeast saw the fewest reductions at 12.8%, while the South led at 19.1%. Cities like Indianapolis (28.7%), Phoenix (28.1%), and Columbus (27.4%) topped national reduction rates as demand cooled.
How Sonoma County stacks up
Our 23.8% reduction rate puts us well above the national average and closer to markets experiencing genuine pricing pressure. The median cut here is $66,070 (6.1%), but average reductions hit $157,541 (8.5%)—dramatically higher than typical national adjustments.
The luxury divide
The luxury market tells a fascinating story about seller confidence. While nearly a third of homes under $1M are cutting prices, just 7.8% of $3M+ properties are reducing. But when high-end sellers do blink? They're slashing prices by over a million dollars on average to attract Sonoma County's shrinking pool of luxury buyers.

City breakdown: Where sellers are cutting deepest
Some communities are seeing widespread adjustments:

Smart Buyers Can Find Great Investments
With these reductions happening there are some deals to be had for smart buyers where sellers are motivated to sell.

A rare example of a 4 bedroom vacation rental eligible property minutes to Sonoma Plaza
Take 595 Michael Drive, Sonoma. This stunning 4-bed, 4-bath estate in prestigious Lomita Estates just dropped nearly 30% to $1,695,000 and comes with AirDNA projections of $182k in annual rental income. With 4,000 square feet of wine country elegance, ensuite bedrooms opening to sweeping vineyard views, a serene koi pond with waterfalls, and city sewer convenience, this property checks every box for savvy vacation rental investors.
What's actually happening
Most sellers aren't panicking—67% of reductions stayed under 10%, suggesting tactical repositioning rather than desperation. But 12 properties (7.5%) slashed prices over 20%, indicating either serious motivation or wild initial overpricing.
The data reveals clear affordability strain in the entry market while luxury properties demonstrate pricing power through scarcity. Properties that reduced average $1.22M in list price, while properties holding steady average $2.09M—lower-priced homes face steeper headwinds.
Reading the tea leaves
Sonoma County's elevated reduction rate compared to the national 18% suggests our market entered this period priced optimistically. With inventory up significantly from recent years, buyers have leverage to wait for realistic pricing. Sellers who adjust early are positioning competitively; those holding firm are betting on limited supply eventually bringing their buyer.
For buyers, this creates genuine opportunity in the sub-$2M range where reduction rates exceed 26%. For sellers, the message is clear: price aggressively from listing or prepare to adjust. The days of "list high and see what happens" appear numbered.
Team News
From Gym Manager to $10M in Sales: New Agent Joins Growing Team
After closing in on nearly $90 million in transactions this year, we're expanding. Jeff Catomer is joining David, Jonathan, and Erika at BruingtonHargreaves—and if you've been around Santa Rosa for a while, you might already know him.
Jeff's been in Sonoma County for over 20 years. Grew up here. Played sports here. Managed gyms and trained clients here. That background in fitness might seem random until you realize that building relationships and helping people reach their goals translates perfectly to real estate.
The numbers back it up:
Over $10 million in home sales in just the past 2 years
Bachelor's in Kinesiology and 10+ years in gym management
Specializes in first-time buyers and second-home investment buyers
Jeff gets the local market because he's lived it. He knows what it's like to navigate Sonoma County as both a longtime resident and someone who understands the investment side of real estate. Whether you're finally ready to buy your first place or you're adding a wine country property to your portfolio, he's built his business on the kind of customer service that actually sticks.
A massive thank you to our clients
None of this growth happens without you. The trust you've placed in us this year has been incredible—and we're building this team to serve you even better in 2025.
Real Estate News
Fed Cuts Rates But Your Mortgage Won't Budge Until 2027
The Fed just cut rates by 0.25% yesterday, but the real story isn't the cut—it's the chaos inside the room.

Six of the Fed's 19 policymakers voted against the reduction, signaling they wanted to hold steady. When officials released their 2026 projections, the division got worse: seven forecasters see zero cuts next year, while eight want at least half a percentage point in reductions. The Fed chair is just one vote on the committee—not a dictator who can slash rates on command.
Most economists expect only one or two quarter-point cuts in 2026, likely in March and June. Some see just one cut all year, maybe not until September. Translation: 30-year mortgage rates will likely hover around 6.1% in 2026, maybe touching 5.9% by 2027.
Here's the math: Every 0.25% Fed cut typically shaves just 0.1–0.15% off mortgage rates, and markets often price in cuts before they happen. Morgan Stanley analysts argue the housing market needs rates in the mid-5% range—roughly a full percentage point lower than today—to trigger a real sales rebound.
What the experts are saying:
Major listing platforms (Zillow, Redfin, Realtor.com) describe 2026 as "more breathing room, not a boom"
Housing economists call it a "gradual thaw" rather than a surge
Mortgage rates are driven more by long-term Treasury yields and risk premiums than Fed funds rate alone
Much of the expected easing is already baked into current mortgage pricing
The reality check: With inflation still sticky and the economy avoiding recession, there's little urgency for aggressive easing. Former Fed officials warn that constant political pressure and internal divisions risk fracturing the institution's ability to communicate a clear policy path.
For Sonoma County, this means planning around 6%+ rates through 2026. If you locked in above 7% recently, refinancing opportunities may emerge late next year. But the days of 3% mortgages? Those aren't coming back.
Lifestyle News
Ancient Roman Breakfast Hack Now Worth $30 in Wine Country
Before you roll your eyes at another made-up food holiday, hear us out. French toast has a surprisingly wild backstory for such a cozy brunch dish, and Sonoma County's doing some genuinely impressive things with it.

Tiramasu French Toast At Acorn Cafe: Light Start to the Day!
The dish that isn't actually French
Ancient Romans were soaking bread in egg and milk centuries before modern France existed. The French call it "pain perdu" (lost bread), a nod to rescuing stale loaves and turning them into something luxurious. One popular story credits 18th-century American innkeeper Joseph French, who supposedly meant to call his dish "French's toast" but forgot the apostrophe. The name stuck.
Around the world it goes by different names: "arme Ritter" (poor knights) in Germany, "torrijas" in Spain, "Bombay toast" in India. In medieval Europe it was budget-friendly survival food, turning stale bread into something rich and satisfying. During early 2000s political tensions with France, some U.S. politicians briefly pushed "freedom toast" on official menus. That didn't last.
Healdsburg's breakfast scene just got serious
Three spots making brunch believers out of everyone:
Acorn Cafe serves tiramisu french toast on Goguette brioche with whipped mascarpone, raspberries, cocoa nibs, and coffee ice cream. It's basically dessert for breakfast and nobody's complaining.
Costeaux French Bakery loads up thick slices of housemade cinnamon walnut bread with berries, fig spread, whipped sweet crème fraîche and Vermont maple syrup. They've been nailing french toast since 1923.
The Parish Cafe goes the French route with pain perdu topped with caramelized bananas and bourbon maple syrup. Because regular maple syrup is for amateurs.
Graton's sleeper hit
Willow Wood Market Cafe fills challah french toast with Black Forest ham, jarlsberg cheese, toasted hazelnuts, and strawberries, plus maple butter and pure maple syrup. It's been voted Best Breakfast in the North Bay multiple times. The Michelin Guide calls it the kind of food you'd expect from a friend's mom in the good old days.
Santa Rosa bringing the heat
Two Railroad Square spots redefining the category:
Marla Bakery tops challah french toast with clementine marmalade and sweetened crème fraîche. Chef Amy Brown uses locally farmed ingredients and changes the menu weekly, so you never know what seasonal twist she'll add.
Grossman's Noshery & Bar created the GB Cinnamon Babka French Toast with two eggs, chicken apple sausage, and orange ginger butter. This New York-style deli opened during the pandemic and landed on Yelp's top 100 Bay Area restaurants. The cinnamon babka is baked in-house.
Why this matters for your Sonoma County lifestyle investment: These restaurants represent the kind of elevated-but-approachable dining culture that drives property values in wine country. When you can get world-class french toast at brunch and Michelin-starred dinners at night, that's the lifestyle dividend your real estate investment delivers.
Real Estate News
Zillow and Redfin Disagree on 2026: Here's What Wine Country Buyers Should Know
Zillow and Redfin just dropped their 2026 predictions, and spoiler alert: it's complicated. Here's what matters for Sonoma County.
The National Picture
Zillow's calling for home values to climb 2.6% nationally through December 2026. Not exactly fireworks, but steady growth beats the alternative. They're predicting inventory will finally start loosening up as more boomers downsize and life events force movement.
Redfin's going bolder, dubbing 2026 "The Great Housing Reset." They see prices rising just 1% nationally, with mortgage rates potentially dropping to 5.9% by year's end if the Fed keeps cutting. Their thesis: frozen homeowners will start moving again as rate-lock anxiety eases.
The Inventory Question
Both agree on one thing: more homes are coming to market. Zillow expects new listings to jump 6.4% nationally as demographic pressure builds. Translation? Your neighbor who's been sitting tight since refinancing at 2.9% might finally list.
For Sonoma County sellers wondering if they missed the window: these predictions suggest 2026 could still favor you, especially in the luxury segment where motivated buyers have been waiting for fresh inventory.
The Sonoma County Angle
Our market doesn't follow national trends perfectly. Wine country's limited supply and Bay Area buyer demand create different dynamics. But if mortgage rates do drop toward 6%, expect those sidelined Bay Area transplants to wake up—and they're still looking at Healdsburg and Sonoma as lifestyle upgrades worth the commute flexibility.
The bigger question: will more inventory mean better deals or just more options? In markets like ours where land constraints limit new construction, even a supply bump might not crater prices the way it could in sprawling metros.
What This Means for You
Sellers: Don't panic about waiting. Spring 2026 could bring motivated buyers with better financing options
Buyers: If rates drop as predicted, your competition increases—getting pre-approved now means you're ready when opportunity hits
Investors: Modest appreciation plus potential rent growth still beats inflation—especially if you're getting wine country lifestyle in the deal
Downsizers: The market's finally shifting to favor movement. If you've been contemplating that Santa Rosa condo or Sebastopol cottage, 2026 might be your year
Both companies emphasize this won't be a boom year, but it could be a normalization year. After the chaos of 2020-2023, boring and predictable sounds pretty good.
Area Guides
Only 6% Is Vineyards: What Wine Country Really Looks Like
Think Sonoma County is all vineyards and sunshine? Most buyers get blindsided by the reality. Vineyards cover just 6% of the land. Temperature swings hit 50 degrees in a single day—coastal Bodega Bay sits at 58°F while inland Kenwood bakes at 103°F. And insurance costs can spike 164% overnight, adding the equivalent of hundreds of thousands to your mortgage. We're breaking down the 6 myths that cost buyers thousands and could derail your Wine Country investment.
Watch the full breakdown to discover why out-of-town agents lose in multiple-offer situations, which microclimate zones save you money on utilities, how Sonoma actually outproduces Napa (yes, really), and the insurance contingency strategy that protects your budget from surprise premium hikes.
What you'll learn:
Why only 18% of households can afford the median $800K home and what the $237K income threshold means for competition
How local agent relationships give you the edge in multiple-offer situations and why listing agents flag out-of-town agents immediately
The three microclimate zones and why your heating bills, garden choices, and outdoor lifestyle depend on which one you pick
Why Sonoma produces 6% of all California wine (more than Napa) across 425 wineries and 19 AVAs—nearly twice Napa's geographic footprint
Which Sonoma County neighborhoods have active Firewise programs and how to add insurance contingencies to your offers
The real affordability picture: yes, homes cost less than San Francisco's $1.4M median, but you'll need twice the county's median income to qualify
Lifestyle News
Sonoma County City Launches Free End-of-Life Planning Program—A First in California
Healdsburg is doing something no other city in Sonoma County has attempted: providing free, comprehensive end-of-life planning as a municipal service. Starting January 2026, the Senior Center will offer everything from legal planning workshops to trained death doulas—all funded by the city and grants, not private practice fees.

Mindful Retirement At Enso Village
City Manager Jeff Kay said he hopes "what we do will be a model for other communities." Based on research by program staff, no other California city appears to offer this level of end-of-life support directly through local government.
The difference? While Sebastopol's senior center hosts monthly "death cafes" for informal conversation and the Sonoma County Council on Aging offers estate planning for fees, Healdsburg is building an integrated program that treats end-of-life preparation as public infrastructure—like libraries or parks.
What's included
"Dying to Talk About It" discussion series
Grief and bereavement support groups
Legal planning workshops (advance directives, estate basics)
Access to trained death doulas and a compassion coordinator
Monthly advice column in Healdsburg Tribune
Future doula training for community members
The money
Initial setup: $25,000 from Community Foundation of Sonoma County
Providence Hospice Foundation: $75,000 covering grief services through 2027
Estimated annual budget: $55,000 (coordinator, materials, tech)
City asking for $25,000 taxpayer funding for remainder of 2025-26 fiscal year
Why it matters for Sonoma County residents
If you've owned property here for decades, you're likely thinking about next steps—whether downsizing, transferring assets to family, or planning care that keeps you in your home. This program addresses the practical side of aging in place: How do you maintain control and dignity while managing healthcare decisions, estate transfer, and family communication?
Council member Ariel Kelley, who recently navigated end-of-life decisions with her father, called it "a really important element as our community continues to age."
Death doula Taya Levine frames it simply: "It's like disaster planning. You don't wait until the fire is at your door to decide what to take."
The program specifically aims to serve Latino families through partnership with Corazón Healdsburg, acknowledging that death planning resources have historically been inaccessible to many communities.
The bigger picture
Sonoma County's 65+ population continues growing as Bay Area retirees relocate here for lifestyle and proximity to family. Programs like this signal cities are adapting infrastructure beyond parks and wine trails—they're building support systems for residents aging into properties they've owned for years.
For now, Healdsburg is the only city in Sonoma County offering free, city-backed end-of-life planning. If the model succeeds, other cities may follow.
Lifestyle News
Why Your Boss Really Wants You Back (Hint: It's Not Productivity)
Remember when working from home was going to ruin real estate forever? Experts predicted a mass exodus from suburbs back to cities. Property values in outlying areas would crater. The commuter lifestyle would roar back.

Working From Home: Better For Employees But Not For Office Leases
Yeah, that didn't age well—especially not in Sonoma County.
The WFH windfall
Remote work redrew California's housing map, and Sonoma County was a big winner. When Bay Area tech workers could swap their daily commute for occasional office visits, they brought their metro salaries north. The result:
Homes with dedicated office space commanded premium pricing
Larger properties with outdoor space saw stronger demand
"Commutable but livable" became the new buyer priority
Translation: Sonoma County's lifestyle amenities suddenly made financial sense for hybrid workers who only needed to hit the office 2 days a week.
The hybrid reality
Despite the return-to-office headlines, flexibility is here to stay:
About 25% of Bay Area workers still work primarily from home
Over 57% of Bay Area employees work remotely at least some of the time
The average hybrid schedule: roughly 2 days per week at home
The dirty secret
Companies love to talk about productivity and collaboration when mandating office returns. But a recent analysis reveals the real driver: those massive office leases they signed pre-pandemic. Billions in commercial real estate obligations are shaping workplace policy more than any performance metric.
The irony? Those empty office buildings are propping up Sonoma County home values. As long as hybrid remains the norm, buyers will keep choosing wine country square footage over downtown proximity.
Current Listings
What’s Happening This Week
Where: Old Courthouse Square, Santa Rosa, CA 95404
When: Saturday, December 13, 2025 • 11:00 AM – 4:00 PM
Why You Should Go: Sip mulled wine while nibbling French pastries at this free European-style holiday market featuring local artisans—plus there's an ice skating rink right on the square if you want to work off those croissants.
Where: 14 Participating Wineries in West Sonoma County
When: Saturday, December 13, 2025 • 11:00 AM – 4:00 PM
Why You Should Go: Your $35 ticket gets you access to ALL 14 local wineries with wine tastings and paired bites—it's like a progressive dinner party through Wine Country without the designated driver guilt.
Where: Raven Performing Arts Theater, 115 North Street, Healdsburg, CA
When: Saturday & Sunday, December 13-14, 2025 • 3:00 PM
Why You Should Go: The Healdsburg Chorus (now in its 37th year!) brings seasonal classics to life in this intimate theater—it's $20 at the door and the perfect way to get into the holiday spirit without fighting mall crowds.
Got friends dreaming of wine country life? Share this newsletter and save them from doomscrolling Zillow
Follow our somewhat professional adventures on Instagram @bruingtonhargreaves
Check our YouTube channel for weekly local market updates (and occasional winery mishaps)
David & Jonathan here – the guys who write about real estate but really just want to talk about our favorite taco trucks. Hit us up about anything Sonoma County (or beyond). Whether you're buying, selling, or just want to know which wineries actually welcome dogs – we've got you covered.







